Reviewed by Andrea Pool
Grade : B+
Book type : Historical Romance
Sensuality : Warm
Review Date : June 8, 2001
Published On : 2001
artistBridgertonBridgerton seriesCinderella storyJulia QuinnNetflixTop 100 Romance
I’ve said it before: I’m a sucker for Cinderella stories. An Offer From a Gentleman definitely takes its inspiration from Cinderella.
Sophie Beckett is the bastard daughter of the Earl of Penwood. She knows it, and she lives in his home as his “ward.” He marries the wicked stepmother, Araminta, who comes with two daughters, Rosamunde and Posy. When the earl dies, his will stipulates that Araminta gets thrice the amount of money if she shelters Sophie than she would if she turns Sophie out. So Sophie becomes the slave of the house until a masquerade ball becomes the catalyst for her to be tossed out of the home. The ball provides the magic moment when Sophie meets Benedict Bridgerton, a mere mister but still a wealthy and eligible bachelor. Circ*mstances bring them back together two years later when he rescues her from being raped at a party. There’s a strong attraction, and Benedict feels responsible for her safety and finds her employment as a maid in his mother’s home.
Sophie’s my kind of girl, especially when she’s around Benedict. She’s sassy and smart, and their repartee reminds me of me and my husband. She stands by her principles, and she’s practical. She knows what is realistic between her and Benedict, but she also can’t control her heart. I like this girl.
Benedict starts off as quite the romantic. He falls totally in love with the mystery woman, and searches for her for two years. One of the things that attracted Benedict to the mystery woman was that she really didn’t know he was a Bridgerton when they met. In two years’ time, though, he becomes more experienced and a little more jaded. When he first met Sophie, he seemed to not have had much experience with women. When he meets her again as herself, he’s got enough experience to ask her to be his mistress, but he’s still not quite the traditional rake. Thank goodness.
When Sophie and Benedict first meet at the masquerade, they set off sparks. Julia Quinn convinced me that they had eyes only for each other, and that they did indeed fall in love at first sight. Their initial meeting seemed pretty magical for this reader. They still had chemistry when they met again two years hence. Benedict was captivated with Sophie-as-mystery-woman, and no other woman ever measured up as a potential wife. Benedict held out for Cinderella. When he doesn’t recognize Sophie, she doesn’t tell him who she really is thinking no good could ever come of it. This, of course, creates problems later.
The rest of the Bridgertons (from the two previous books in this series), Penelope Featherington, and, of course Lady Whistledown, all make appearances. Violet Bridgerton, the matriarch of the family, has quite a major role in the second half of the book, and the way she rescues Sophie and delivers justice to Araminta, the wicked stepmother, is priceless. The confrontation between Violet, Sophie, Araminta, Benedict and Posy, Araminta’s less-well-liked child, were quite possibly my favorite part of the book.
Benedict and Sophie’s romance ended quite satisfactorily. Julia Quinn delivers another winner in Benedict’s story. While the humor was less laugh-out-loud obvious than in other stories, it’s still here, as is the sweet love story and likable characters. Quinn also delivers a bit of a cliffhanger as Lady Whistledown decides to put down her pen and live life. I’m still not sure if I know who she is. I can’t wait for Colin’s story.
Reviewed by Andrea Pool
Grade : B+
Book type : Historical Romance
Sensuality : Warm
Review Date : June 8, 2001
Published On : 2001
artistBridgertonBridgerton seriesCinderella storyJulia QuinnNetflixTop 100 Romance
Recent Comments
Dabney Grinnan commented I actually love Phin's (Written on Your Skin) and James' (Bound By...
Caz Owens commented I think this is their best book yet - if you do...
Bona commented Great books with heroines with alcoholic problems that I can easily remember:...
Manjari commented For me, romance novels are an escape so a main character with...
Edna commented I loved this one! I did not read the author's others mostly...
Jessica commented I'm tempted to buy a copy, just so I have it.
Andrea Pool
- Open Season by Linda Howard
- Double Trouble
- Indiscreet by Mary Balogh
- Goddess of the Sea by P.C. Cast
Subscribe
Login
Please login to comment
24 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Robin
Guest
09/13/2021 1:25 pm
Like a lot of people, I got into the Bridgerton series thanks to Netflix! I’m enjoying the story in this third Bridgerton book, even though it’s the umpteenth take on Cinderella! :-) HOWEVER, I was disappointed to find that Ms. Quinn used contemporary language to convey the thoughts of people who live in Regency England (and the editor didn’t catch it). Sorry, but “who’s kidding whom” is NOT a phrase used by 19th-century Britons! As a former history major, nothing takes me out of a story like text not appropriate to a particular time. Nevertheless, I’m planning to finish reading the series and I look forward to the next season of “Bridgerton”!
2
chrisreader
Member
04/28/2021 4:48 pm
I finally got around to reading this one. It was kind of a big nothing for me. Sophie didn’t show a lot of good sense. Every time someone tried to help her she pushed them off. Why was she still hiding who she was by the end? Most of the book made no sense.
It’s another one of those books that are based almost entirely on legal nonsense. Wills have Executors to make sure their contents are known to the beneficiaries and that the bequests are carried out. That’s all just ignored here so the crazy evil stepmother can have her way over someone who was acknowledged as his Ward. She wasn’t someone no one knew about, her father made legal arrangements for her.
I enjoyed Violet and the Bridgerton sisters in this book but Benedict was wasted and Sophie who started out sparkling, was kind of a drip.
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to chrisreader
04/28/2021 4:59 pm
Totes agree. It’s a lesser Bridgerton.
1
Caz Owens
Editor
12/17/2020 7:16 am
This is one of the weaker books in the series, IMO, and not one I’ve been inclined to revisit. It’s not a bad book by any means, just not especially memorable in the way that some of the others are.
2
Sonia
Guest
Reply to Caz Owens
12/17/2020 7:47 am
Agree… I just think there are two specific scenes in this book that colored my perspective of it into a less than pleasant one. However, I read it a long time ago and have not re-read it, nor parts of it (as I did with books #2, #4, #5 and #7, the ones I liked best) so perhaps I’m not being fair.
1
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to Caz Owens
12/17/2020 7:58 am
It was so bland compared to the one that preceded it. I too have never gone back and read it again. I have some memory that surely can’t be correct.
It’s kinda a spoiler so don’t read on if you don’t want to know anything about the book.
Did they have sex the first night they met up against a wall?
1
Caz Owens
Editor
Reply to Dabney Grinnan
12/18/2020 3:53 am
The fact that I can’t remember probably just goes to show what an unmemorable book it is…
1
AlwaysReading
Guest
Reply to Caz Owens
12/18/2020 5:22 am
I don’t think it is! They did make out against a wall though.
1
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to AlwaysReading
12/18/2020 6:25 am
That would make much more sense.
1
chrisreader
Member
Reply to Dabney Grinnan
04/28/2021 4:41 pm
Nope just a kiss.
1
Lisa Fernandes
Member
10/05/2017 2:54 am
Not my absolute favorite Bridgerton, but pretty good. Sophie and Benedict are adorable.
1
Amanda
Member
09/12/2017 1:16 pm
This is possibly my least favorite book in the Bridgerton series, tied maybe with the last one. I used to like it more, but the last time I reread (last year, maybe?) I just wasn’t feeling it at all, so it’s not one I plan to read again if I want to revisit the series.
1
Caz Owens
Editor
09/10/2017 7:06 pm
I have to say I’m with Blackjack in that I probably wouldn’t have included this in my Top 100. I’ve recently been revisiting the series in audio (as the first five books have recently been recorded) and I think it’s one of the weaker entries. I’ve got a soft spot for The Viscount Who Loved Me, which is the first JQ I ever read and my favourites are When He Was Wicked and To Sir Phillip With Love, which both showed how well JQ can do the less fluffier stuff. Still, it’s a strong series, and even the weaker books are entertaining and readable.
1
Blackjack
Reply to Caz Owens
09/10/2017 9:37 pm
I want to read To Sir Phillip with Love. That has long been in my TBR pile. Thank you for reminding me of it!
1
Blackjack
Reply to Blackjack
09/10/2017 9:39 pm
BTW, I don’t know why my log-in image keeps changing. It’s so weird :)
1
Caz Owens
Editor
Reply to Blackjack
09/11/2017 7:38 am
Sir Phillip was actually one of the two books in the series I had never read, and the reviews I’d read were somewhat mixed so I wasn’t sure what to expect. But I listened to the new audio recently and it was fabulous. Not a fluffy story and the hero is problematic, but there are good reasons for that and there were some real lump-in-throat moments.
2
Carrie G
Guest
Reply to Caz Owens
12/17/2020 4:11 pm
I had a problem with the depiction of mental illness in To Sir Phillip,With Love,although overall I liked the book.
Spoiler!
The way we are guided to see Marina as a burden and an impediment to Phillip’s happiness made me sad. Quinn was gentle in her approach, but the end result was that we’re all “happy” Marina is no longer there. In the end, Marina’s clinical depression is a trope to give Phillip a sad backstory.
1
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to Caz Owens
09/11/2017 7:54 am
My favorite is Romancing Mr. Bridgerton distantly followed by When He Was Wicked.
1
Amanda
Member
Reply to Dabney Grinnan
09/12/2017 1:17 pm
These are my two favorites as well, but only flipped!
1
Lil
Guest
Reply to Caz Owens
12/17/2020 5:15 pm
To Sir Phillip With Love is actually my favorite of the Bridgerton books, edging out even The Viscount Who Loved Me. I’ve yet to read An Offer From a Gentleman—something about it keeps putting me off.
1
Blackjack
Guest
09/10/2017 5:38 pm
I found this entertaining though the stereotypes of the Cinderella heroine in need of rescuing by the prince and the dastardly villains populating the story annoyed me too much to love the book. The heroine is plucky and feisty and in the end punches people and clobbers the hero by throwing a candle at his head. Not terribly relatable and not really a book I would put in a top 100 list, but then again Quinn is not really an author I gravitate toward.
1
mel burns
Guest
Reply to Blackjack
09/11/2017 2:31 pm
I agree, this book doesn’t IMO belong in the top 100 list.
1
Cindy
Guest
09/10/2017 2:14 pm
Hmm, I’m thinking I should read again too! I don’t remember a lot of those plot aspects.
Though I think I read the review carefully, I’m wondering why the reviewer did not give the book an ‘A’ -?
1
Anne Marble AAR
Guest
09/09/2017 7:28 pm
I’m glad to see this one! :) I know I read it a while ago, but you’ve reminded me that this is something I should read again — a nice break from all the twisty psychological thrillers I’ve read lately.
1
